Fit & Proper?

(original edit of article for Taxi magazine).

As reported in the last issue of Taxi, TfL are advertising Uber on the Taxis & Minicabs section of their website. Could the LTDA advertise on the TfL website too? Or Addison Lee? Is it just a matter of paying so much money that TfL can’t resist?
It seems inappropriate for our licensing authority to use advertising for this purpose. Putting aside the fact that Uber and their drivers are subject to legal action in London and around the world, it seems inappropriate for our licensing authority to take advertising of this nature. It’s like the NHS promoting individual doctors or medical practices, and those with the most money getting a mention.
It all leaves a nasty taste in the mouth at a time where the taxi trade is being undermined by a virtual operator that’s being chased around the world with lawsuits. If I went over to Paris and tried to operate my cab business I’m sure the Parisian equivalent of TfL would say “Non.” And quite rightly so. Following a stiff warning letter or two, I’d fully expect an invitation to discuss the matter with m’learned friends in a court of law, and a single ticket back to St Pancras International. If I brazened it out and decided to continue I wouldn’t expect TfL to renew my licence should I ever return. I would have shown contempt for the laws of the land and would not be deemed a fit and proper person. Uber continue to operate in the European cities they have been banned in, showing total disregard for the laws of those countries. And they’re still considered worthy of an operator’s licence in London.
Maybe the LTDA and Addison Lee do have adverts on the TfL website. I didn’t get that far in my research as I was so mesmerised by Uber’s advert claiming that I could earn £1200 per week as a driver. If I could make £1200 as a day driver I’d be a happy man, so I ticked the information box to find out more. The advert says I need to be a current taxi driver “certified and licensed by the city”, and my vehicle needs to be “a commercial taxi Vehicle.” I easily satisfy Uber’s stringent specifications so wanted to know how to claim my £1200 per week. Unfortunately there were no further details. I would have had to leave my contact details for someone to get back to me. This was as far as I was prepared to venture into the world of Uber so I left it there.
I imagine I’d have to work every hour God sends in order to pull in that kind of money. Scare stories concerning tachographs in cabs were prevalent a few years’ ago. Maybe it’s time to look again at a restriction driving hours? I’m just saying…
Meanwhile, Uber have recently been fined $128,000 by a French court for falsely marketing its car-pooling service, and its drivers have been warned that they face criminal conviction. That’s not a lot of money, but it might put its drivers off if they think they might attract criminal convictions. India are also on their case over tax. The state of Nevada has also been added to the growing list of places banning Uber. They’ve been banned from offering their shared ride service pending a court hearing, and five drivers have been cited by regulators. They could be fined up to $10,000. A Las Vegas driver, Michael Elsner, told reporters that Uber are worth more than $18 million: “do you think the Nevada Taxicab authority is going to win? I mean, come on, come on.” Herein lies the problem; the company is too powerful. Any fines that the Las Vegas drivers receive will be reimbursed by Uber, according to Uber’s Western Region spokeswoman, Eve Behrend: “Uber vigorously defends the rights of our partner drivers and firmly stands by them when they are wrongly cited or impounded. We will cover and financial or legal costs associated with these unjust actions”. It puts Addison Lee’s promise to reimburse bus lane fines in perspective, doesn’t it?
Uber have exploited technology and have undermined the taxi – and private hire – trade worldwide. The fear is that they’ve become so powerful that no-one can stop them. Wild West Sheriffs have tried running them out of town, but they keep riding back on their shiny black steeds. If they’re worth over $18 million, that’s a lot of money. But it’s not finite. If they face expensive lawsuits and end up paying all their driver’s fines they’ll run out of cash eventually.
The most important element in this scenario is the drivers. They are also the weakest link. If the drivers start to pick up damaging criminal convictions they will lose confidence. The company will then surely fail. As for London drivers, if they get criminal convictions won’t that mean their TfL private hire licences will be revoked? Will they continue to put up with all the hassle – even for £1200 per week?

Leave a comment

Filed under Published Articles

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s